Ill not have you around him, picking up his habits and learning Lord-knows-what (Lee, 228). whenever a white man does that to a black man, no matter who he is, how rich he is, or how fine a family he comes from, that white man is trash (Lee, 224). 2021, https://www.enotes.com/topics/to-kill-a-mockingbird/questions/in-to-kill-a-mockingbird-compare-and-contrast-27449. She believes women should be demure and wear dresses and pearls. etiquette and behavior, and prefers to live openly and honestly One such clash is over cousin Joshua, whom Aunt Alexandra admires deeply, because he has brought fame to the Finch family by writing a book, and simply because he is part of the family. Atticus is very uncomfortable with forcing heredity on the children and the children sense it. Atticus, along with Calpurnia and his children depict a style of thinking too modern for that time; a feeling of tolerance and acceptance and the ability to look past a person's exterior. She's married, but Scout insists that her husband isn't worth mentioning. In contrast, Atticus is a forward-thinking, tolerant man, who believes in racial equality and is not afraid to challenge Maycomb's racist culture. When asked about the reason for her trip, Aunt Alexandra tells Jem and Scout that she and Atticus think that because they are growing up so fast, they could use some feminine influence, especially Scout. He is a highly looked upon lawyer in the small town of Maycomb county. What does Atticus mean when he says "Simply because we were licked a hundred years before we startedis no reason for us not to try to win"in To Kill a Mockingbird? Aunt Alexandra and Miss Maudie Atkinson, Racial Relations in the Southern United States. Aunt Alexandra's understanding of trash is quite different. Scout wouldn't mind if she went back to that family either. People in societies and families need role models who possess qualities such as respecting other people who have different, Alexandra ploys to make Scout more ' Lady like ' and berating Scout for not wanting to wear dresses makes Scout grow to dislike her Aunt. Aunt Alexandra believes that because the Finch family has land and comes from a line of landowners that have been around for generation that they deserve respect and are on the higher end of the social circle of Maycomb. How are they alike and how are they different? properly as she feels a lady should. Boo Radley and Tom Robinson, Next In this way, Scout is also a victim of this old-fashioned system for judging individuals, and as Aunt Alexandra tries to mold her into the image of Southern femininity, she gets a clear taste of what it is like to be held up to a stereotyped identity rather than being allowed to simply be herself. Atticus 's sister. Also, some of the lines were said in a different order in the movie. He is considered to be fair, just, and honest. He teaches his children to empathize with other people, to be tolerant, and not to be judgmental. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Your email address will not be published. Aunt Alexandra is scandalized to find out that the children went to First Purchase with Calpurnia, and is even more shocked when scout expresses the desire to visit Calpurnia outside of home. But stayed focused on doing his job the right way no matter his clients skin color., The novel To Kill a Mockingbird is a captivating story about a young girl named Jean- Louise Finch (Scout) and the various experiences of her childhood. He is not a hypocrite, does not judge others, and could care less about heredity. "In To Kill A Mockingbird, compare and contrast Atticus and Alexandra." Latest answer posted November 20, 2020 at 10:58:48 AM. As for the Finchs Landing, if the audience wants intensity, Scout walloping the big mouthed Cousin Francis will definitely, Atticus sent aunt Alexandra to play kind of a mom role in scout's life. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. Character Analysis Becauseheistrash, thats why you cant play with him. Unlike Alexandra, Atticus does not fit into Maycomb's society and is an outcast because of his progressive beliefs. All of the characters in the book demonstrate one-dimensional and three-dimensional tendencies but Jem and Arthur are those that provide the greatest insight to the latter., Atticus who is a lawyer. Already a member? Aunt Alexandra cannot distinguish between poor people who are hardworking members of society and people like Bob Ewell, who are poor and morally detestable. Aunt Alexandra refuses to be associated with black and the poor. She is appalled that Scout acts so much like a little boy rather than being and dressing properly as she feels a lady should. Robinson was accused of raping a white woman named Mayella. See answer (1) Best Answer Copy Aunt Alexandra is very traditional where Atticus is progressive. This is a drastic contrast to Atticus's liberal parenting style, and the fact that he pays no heed to what society might think, and does what he thinks is right. Aunt Alexandra is very conscious of Maycomb's social mores, chooses to live within its constrictions, and "given the slightest chance she would exercise her royal prerogative: she would arrange, advise, caution, and warn." The only similarity I can think of is that they both care about others, but in very different ways. her the way she is, which, at the time, is more of a tomboy than a little 'fame' she might have), social standing, prejudices, outward Is it wrong to say excuse my left when giving someone an item with your left hand? Atticus does not believe in social class and breeding to separate people. Scout acts so much like a little boy rather than being and dressing Atticus and Alexandra are both loving, caring people who are devoted to their families and to each other. Aunt Alexandra is a formidable lady and is the only Finch sibling who stayed at Finch's Landing, the family's old plantation. Being a single father, he tries his best to take care of his two kids Scout and Jem. Jem and Scout will have better futures and successes based off of the strong connection with their. tries to reinforce his sister's wishes, Scout knows that he loves In another part of the book, the reader learns that Calpurnia has known Atticus since they were both children. What does Scout find in the knothole of the tree in the novelTo Kill a Mockingbird? In this journal, I will be characterizing Atticus., If a newer film adaption of To Kill A Mockingbird were created, it would need to include many of the characters/scenes that were left out of the first film. bookmarked pages associated with this title. Although, one may argue that these characters/scenes were left out of the first film adaption because they are unimportant, provide no lessons, and are useless towards the plot. Alexandra reveals her prejudice against lower-class, poor white families by telling Scout that no matter how many times someone scrubs Walter Jr. he will never be like Jem, which she says before she comments on the drinking streak in Walter's family. cold and there" while Miss Maudie is warm enough to pop out her dentures for Scout to see. Compare and contrast Atticus and aunt Alexandra in To Kill a Mockingbird.? This theme of tolerance is also portrayed in Calpurnia, when she tells Lula to allow the children into First Purchase, on the basis of a common God. Miss Maudie is the person who ends that line of conversation with two sentences. Scout says the following about it, It was a quiet digging in, never outright irritation. On her insistence he tries to tell Jem and Scout to behave in a manner fitting of the Finches; he even tells Scout to apologize to her aunt when she is rude, even though Aunt had no right to interfere. He sees no harm in letting Scout visit Calpurnia, and would have probably agreed if Aunt Alexandra had not intervened, and said no. Compare and contrast Atticus to Jem in To Kill a Mockingbird. During this meeting Scout is required to act Feminine, even though she would rather be playing with Jem and Dill. When Jem asked if they could have Walter home for diner (after Atticus' revelation). He knew it would take time for it to happen, Scout showed courage and never gave up on aunt alexandra even though every single day she wanted to., There are many differences between the movie and the book. The idea of a white man representing a colored man causes a lot of controversy between him and his children throughout the town. appearance, and southern hospitality/graces. For example, the movie had two thief scenes when the book only had one. 53 terms. Aunt Alexandra, along with the rest of the Finch Household does not approve of Atticus defending a Tom Robinson, a black man. She wears men's overalls when she works in the garden, but is equally comfortable in more traditional garb. What we learn from connections within the family takes the place of instincts that program the behaviour of animals. Neither Davis nor Atticus allow others opinions to affect theirs, knowing that there are always multiple stories and perspectives for every event. Are elliptical galaxies egg-shaped galaxies without spiral arms of interstellar gas and dust? 8. Accessed 17 July 2023. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. Lizabeth is a young girl who lives in a poverty struck family, in the short story, Marigolds. Because heistrash, thats why you cant play with him. He has two children, Jem and Jean Louise Finch. She looks down on people like the Cunninghams while Atticus sees them as simple hard working people. She thus extends these thoughts to her feelings about poor families like the Cunninghams, telling Scout that young Walter is "trash" and that she will surely pick up "his habits and [learn] Lord-knows-what" from his association. He always talks about how he has to be the same person everywhere he goes. Alexandra is told by Atticus that Tom has been shot trying to escape the prison yard., It is not our differences that divide us, it is our inability to recognize, accept, and celebrate those differences, said Audre Lorde, a Caribbean-American writer, and civil rights activist. Like Atticus, she stays within bounds, but follows her own code. What color does blue and green and pink make when mixed together? Demonstrate the theme of loneliness and isolation in To Kill a Mockingbird by comparing and contrasting Atticus Finch and Mayella Ewell. Compare and Contrast Essay The novel, To Kill a Mockingbird, by Harper Lee includes the contradictory characters Atticus and Alexandra. What does Atticus mean when he says "Simply because we were licked a hundred years before we startedis no reason for us not to try to win"in To Kill a Mockingbird? . is. eNotes Editorial, 1 Apr. similarity I can think of is that they both care about others, but Atticus dismisses a person's family background and places the emphasis on how they treat others. Aunt Alexandra and Miss Maudie are roughly the same age and grew up as neighbors at Finch's Landing. Atticus, although he is initially mildly surprised, remains unperturbed; rather he seems to enjoy Scout's account of the church trip. Latest answer posted November 20, 2020 at 10:58:48 AM. He allows both Jem and Scout to Atticus fulfills the role of a parent by nurturing Dill when he needs it most, providing him with food, shelter and more importantly trust and support. Aunt Alexandra represents old Southern attitudes towards heritage, race and family relations. progressive. Atticus is a man with high morals and respects all people around him, regardless of what they think of him. from Indiana University of Pennsylvania. But then one day it finally clicked for scout. When Aunt Alexandra states, "'I can't say I approve of everything he does, Maudie, but he's my brother,'" Miss Maudie reminds her that Atticus is doing a wonderful thing and that many in the town support him, even if that support is quiet. He was all for finding him innocent and showing good sense regardless of the opinions and racism of everyone else.